Rent reservation: when and how landlords make one

Lease with fountain pen and stamp on the desk of a property management company

In short: A rent reservation records that the landlord is not fully asserting a rent adjustment to which it is entitled; it is only effective if it is clearly justified and quantified in francs or as a percentage of the rent. This is required by Art. 18 of the Ordinance on the Lease of Residential and Commercial Premises (VMWG). Without a reservation, it is assumed at a later adjustment that the rent last set provided the landlord with a sufficient return.

What is a rent reservation?

In Switzerland, rents in ongoing leases are generally adjusted using the relative method: the starting point is the last binding rent setting, and the changes since then are asserted, for example in the reference rate, inflation or costs. Under the principle of good faith, tenants may assume that the rent last set is sufficient for the landlord.

The reservation breaks this assumption. Art. 18 VMWG states that if the landlord does not fully assert the rent adjustment to which it is entitled, it must specify this reservation in francs or as a percentage of the rent. The Zurich courts summarise the consequence: without a reservation, it is assumed at a future increase that the rent demanded leads to a sufficient return and corresponds to the customary local comparative rent.

The Federal Supreme Court has long required the reservation to state exactly which increase factors the landlord is reserving. A lease clause that merely states the mortgage rate on which the rent is based is not a reservation (BGE 117 II 161).

When do landlords make a reservation?

A reservation always belongs to a rent setting. If the rent is not adjusted at all, the landlord can in any case assert all changes since the last rent setting later.

OccasionTypical caseWhat to note
Conclusion of the leaseThe previous tenant's rent is taken over; inflation or costs since the last adjustment are not includedA relative reservation is only permitted if the previous rent is carried over into the new lease (BGer 4A_549/2016)
Conclusion of the leaseThe rent is deliberately below the comparative rent or does not provide a sufficient returnAbsolute reasons only: return, gross return for new buildings, customary local rent
Rent increaseNot all reasons are fully used, for example only the reference rate but not inflation and costsQuantify the remainder per reason, on the form or in the accompanying letter to which the form refers
Rent reductionThe reduction is passed on without offsetting inflation or costsReserve the reasons not offset, quantified
Reply to a reduction requestInflation and costs exceed the reduction claimThe rent stays the same, the remainder can be reserved; an increase requires the form

More on replying to a reduction request on our page on rent reduction.

Which reasons can a reservation cover?

A reservation can be based on the same reasons as a rent increase. The Tenants' Association, SRF and several property managers consistently name:

  • Reference rate, inflation or general cost increases are not up to date.
  • Value-enhancing investments have not yet been passed on, or only partly.
  • The equity earns an insufficient return (net or gross return).
  • For new buildings, the cost-covering gross return has not been reached.
  • The customary local rent has not been fully used.

Caution is advised with customary local rents. The reservation is permitted, but the later proof is difficult: comparable properties by location, size, fittings, condition and construction period are needed (Art. 11 VMWG). Beobachter mentions five comparable apartments; Casafair calls this reservation disputed.

A special rule applies when a new lease is concluded. Because the initial rent is generally reviewed using the absolute method, a reservation in the lease may only name absolute reasons, i.e. return, gross return or comparative rent. Relative reasons such as unused inflation are only permitted if the landlord takes over the previous tenant's rent and continues the existing rent structure (BGer 4A_549/2016 consid. 3.1).

How must a rent reservation be worded?

The requirements are strict. A reservation must be so clear that the tenants recognise that the landlord will later rely on exactly these reasons. HEV Zürich, the Tenants' Association and the Zurich courts consistently require it to be:

  • Clearly expressed: recognisable as a reservation of a later increase.
  • Justified: with the specific reason, for example “inflation since [date of last rent setting]”.
  • Quantified: in francs or as a percentage of the rent (Art. 18 VMWG).
  • Separate: with several reasons, a separate amount for each.
WordingSufficient?Why
“Subject to inflation.”nonot quantified
“Insufficient increase, further adjustments reserved.”noneither reason nor amount
“The rent is based on a reference rate of 1.25 %.” (in the lease)nostatement of the basis of calculation, not a reservation of an increase (BGE 117 II 161)
“Reserved: inflation since 1 April 2025, CHF 8 per month; cost increase since 1 April 2025, CHF 5 per month.”yesreason, period and amount per reason
“Reserved: value-enhancing share of the 2026 window renovation not yet passed on, CHF 45 per month.”yesspecific investment and amount

In practice, francs are clearer than percentages. Anyone stating a percentage should say clearly which rent it refers to.

Example 1: rent increase with reservation

Assume the reference rate rises from 1.25 % to 1.50 % at a future announcement. An apartment costs CHF 2000 net; the last rent setting was a year ago, and the consumer price index has since risen by 1.0 % (sample value).

ReasonCalculationPermittedClaimedReserved
Reference rate +0.25 points3 % of CHF 2000CHF 60CHF 60CHF 0
Inflation 1.0 %40 % of 1.0 % = 0.4 %CHF 8CHF 0CHF 8
Cost increase (Zurich flat rate)0.25 % x 1 yearCHF 5CHF 0CHF 5
TotalCHF 73CHF 60CHF 13

The landlord increases the rent to CHF 2060 using the official form and states on the form: “Reserved: inflation CHF 8 and cost increase CHF 5 per month, as of [date].” If it wants to use the reservation later, the form and the deadline of at least ten days before the notice period begins are required again (Art. 269d CO, see rent increase).

Example 2: reservation against a reduction request

A year later, the reference rate falls again from 1.50 % to 1.25 %. The tenants request a reduction. Since the increase, the consumer price index has risen by 0.5 % (sample value), and one year has passed.

ItemWithout reservationWith reservation
Reference rate −0.25 points: −2.91 % of CHF 2060−CHF 59.95−CHF 59.95
Inflation since the increase: 40 % of 0.5 % = 0.2 %+CHF 4.12+CHF 4.12
Cost increase since the increase: 0.25 % x 1 year+CHF 5.15+CHF 5.15
Reservation from the increaseno reservation+CHF 13.00
Reduction per month−CHF 50.68−CHF 37.68
Effect of a rent reservation in the example: without a reservation the rent falls by CHF 50.68 per month, with a CHF 13 reservation by only CHF 37.68.

The documented reservation reduces the reduction by CHF 13 per month, provided it is justified in substance. If the tenants dispute it, the landlord must prove the reserved inflation and costs. According to SRF, a reserve that was mentioned neither in the lease nor on the form may not be asserted.

Where is the reservation recorded?

At the conclusion of the lease, the reservation belongs in the lease; for an increase, on the official form or in the accompanying letter to which the form expressly refers (Art. 19 para. 1bis VMWG for the reasons). According to HEV Zürich, mentioning it on the form is advantageous but not a condition of validity; the Federal Supreme Court has not decided the question. Using the form and accompanying letter together is the safe route.

For a reduction or in the reply to a reduction request, no official form is prescribed. The reservation is then stated in writing in the notice to all tenants on the lease.

What effect does a rent reservation have?

A reservation is initially a declaration of intent. It does not increase the rent and does not automatically entitle the landlord to refuse a reduction request (SRF, Tenants' Association). Tenants cannot challenge it on its own; it is therefore also not deemed accepted if they do nothing about it.

Only when the landlord uses the reservation, i.e. increases the rent or refuses a reduction on that basis, can it be reviewed. Tenants can challenge an increase before the conciliation authority within 30 days (Art. 270b CO), and a refused reduction also within 30 days (Art. 270a para. 2 CO). The conciliation authority first checks whether the reservation is formally correct and only then whether it is justified in substance (Tenants' Association).

Who bears the burden of proof?

The landlord. The Zurich courts state that, when using the reservation later, the landlord bears the burden of proving that the increase claim exists, and advise making reservations only if one is convinced they are justified. In practice this means: the calculation and supporting documents belong with the reservation, not just in the conciliation proceedings. In conciliation proceedings, tenants can request the relevant documents for all reasons asserted (Art. 20 para. 2 VMWG).

Does a rent reservation expire?

There is no statutory deadline; Art. 18 VMWG does not specify one.

A reservation is, however, easily lost through omission:

  • Repeat it at every further increase. As long as it has not been used, the reservation must be recorded again at every rent increase, settlement and judgment (HEV Zürich, law.ch).
  • Partly used: restate the remainder. Anyone who only uses part of it records the remainder as a reservation again (Casafair, Hugo Steiner).
  • New lease: renew it. A reservation only applies between the parties to the lease. Towards new tenants it must be made again in the new lease (HEV Zürich).
  • Check the basis. With a return reservation, the basis of calculation may have changed since (Casafair).

Process for property managers: document reservations per lease

A reservation is only useful if it can still be found and proven years later, often after a change in management. For property managers with many properties and portfolios, it therefore belongs in the lease data, not in an old letter in the archive.

1. Check at every rent setting. Before every increase, reduction and new lease, clarify whether everything permissible is being demanded. If not: make a reservation deliberately or deliberately waive it.

2. Quantify and justify. Record the amount in francs, period and calculation for each reason. Avoid general wording.

3. Record per lease. These details belong to every reservation:

FieldExample
ReasonInflation since the last rent setting
AmountCHF 8 per month
BasisNet rent CHF 2060, index level [value]
Made onDate and document (lease, form, reply letter)
Supporting documentsCalculation, index values, cost breakdown
Statusopen, partly used, used

4. Use them for requests and increases. When a reduction request comes in, check the lease's reservations first. When increasing, record the remainder again.

5. Decide again when tenants change. The reservation does not pass to new tenants. With the new lease, check whether a reservation is permitted and sensible.

6. File documents centrally. With Allthings Dossier, leases and notices for each tenancy are kept in one place and can be made available to tenants in the tenant portal and app.

Sources

  1. Ordinance on the Lease of Residential and Commercial Premises (VMWG): Art. 11, 18, 19, 20 (fedlex, version of 1 October 2025)
  2. Swiss Code of Obligations (CO): Art. 269d, 270a, 270b (fedlex, version of 1 October 2026)
  3. Federal Supreme Court: BGE 117 II 161 (sufficiently clear reservation)
  4. Federal Supreme Court: judgment 4A_549/2016 of 9 February 2017 (reservation in the lease, relative and absolute method)
  5. Courts of the Canton of Zurich: rent increase (reservation and burden of proof)
  6. Swiss Tenants' Association: rent increase information sheet, calculation methods
  7. SRF Espresso: lower reference rate, no rent reduction because of a rent reserve (26.09.2025)
  8. Beobachter: what does a rent reservation mean? (03.04.2025)
  9. HEV Zürich: rent adjustment by using a rent reservation (10/2005, archive)
  10. law.ch: increase reservation
  11. Casafair: pitfalls of the rent reservation (09.09.2024)

Information as of 4 November 2026.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is a rent reservation?

The landlord's declaration that it is not fully asserting a permissible rent adjustment and is reserving the remainder for later. It must be justified and quantified in francs or per cent (Art. 18 VMWG).

What is a rent reserve in the lease?

The same as a rent reservation. In the lease it is only permitted with absolute reasons, unless the previous tenant's rent is taken over.

Is a rent reservation permitted?

Yes, if it meets the formal requirements. Whether it is justified in substance is only reviewed when the landlord uses it.

Can tenants challenge a rent reservation?

Not on its own. Only the increase or refused reduction based on the reservation can be challenged, in each case within 30 days before the conciliation authority.

How does the landlord assert a reservation?

With a rent increase on the official form, at least ten days before the notice period begins, or as an objection to a reduction request.

What does the reference rate have to do with a rent reservation?

A rise in the reference rate that was not passed on can be a reason for a reservation. The reservation must then state the rate on which the rent is based and the amount reserved.

Does a rent reservation become time-barred?

The law sets no deadline. However, it must be repeated at every further increase and made again with a new lease, otherwise it is lost.

Is “subject to inflation” in the lease enough?

No. Without an amount in francs or per cent and without precise reasons, the reservation is ineffective.

Easy. Pragmatic. Swiss. This is how real estate business works today.

Book an appointment now
Customer login
Next
Contact

Contact the Allthings team

Our team usually answers within 24 hours.

Fill out the contact form

We process your data to answer your request. For more details, see our privacy policy.

Submit
Thank you! We will get back to you shortly.
Something went wrong while sending. Please try again or write to info@allthings.me.